Recruitment and Retention for 2025

RedVHeartbeat

SGI NSW Cup
25 or 26.
26, four extra years on Sloan. He has also had a better team ahead of him for much of his career and probably faced far less scrutiny than Sloan has copped. Those four years did not stop Sloan running rings round him in one play last year. Seems every one here has forgotten that or rather choose to forget it.
 

Dragons Chris

SGI NSW Cup
People expect too much from Sloan. If unfair to compared him with established fullbacks with years of cred. His game is steadier these days, less of the risky fancy stuff. Still, this is a moot point as now he does not have to play in the most difficult position in the game. I reckon he can handle the flank, if he is not put there I see him asking for a release.
I see him asking for a release. I think being on the wing exposes his main weakness of not being able to break tackles. Or getting pushed back a long way in tackles.
 

Dragons Chris

SGI NSW Cup
26, four extra years on Sloan. He has also had a better team ahead of him for much of his career and probably faced far less scrutiny than Sloan has copped. Those four years did not stop Sloan running rings round him in one play last year. Seems every one here has forgotten that or rather choose to forget it.
That's true but he was/is a big part of that "better team".
 

RedVHeartbeat

SGI NSW Cup
Croft is ok.
He is the clubs #1 choice if somehow his manager can get him out of his contract to join us for '25. Why Atkinson. These are moderate stats for someone being hyped as he is, while Crofts S L footage shows he has exceptional skill.
 

Dragons Chris

SGI NSW Cup
He is the clubs #1 choice if somehow the guys manager can get him out of his contract to join us for '25. Why Atkinson. These are moderate stats for someone being hyped as he is while Crofts S L footage shows he has exceptional skill.
TBH, I don't know. Only basing it on what I have seen from Croft and the comments I've seen about Atkinson here. We might be in some trouble next year.
 

RedVHeartbeat

SGI NSW Cup
But most of a wingers game these days is helping out the forwards for the first 2 or 3 tackles after clearing kicks.
That is true and most of these guys are built like brick crap houses. Sione Finau may not be the biggest winger but he has the power that all Polynesians seen to possess. Sloan has a skinny aborigine frame. Still if he can bulk up as in add muscle like JAC, I see him being in his mold and the Fox has managed a solid career.
 

Dragons Chris

SGI NSW Cup
That is true and most of these guys are built like brick crap houses. Sione Finau may not be the biggest winger but he has the power that all Polynesians seen to possess. Sloan has a skinny aborigine frame. Still if he can bulk up as in add muscle like JAC, I see him being in his mold and the Fox has managed a solid career.
If he can. Right now, I think JAC has at least 10kgs on Sloan.
 

Edward

SGI NSW Cup
Only 5k mate between the pair. So an extra 5k of muscle on Sloans frame will make a huge difference to his being able to hold his own in tackles.
Still young enough to pack on several more kgs of muscle. Hope he can and starts running hard. If he does that and gains the confidence to match, Gutho might find himself under a lot of pressure.
 

Illusion

SGI NSW Cup
He is the clubs #1 choice if somehow his manager can get him out of his contract to join us for '25. Why Atkinson. These are moderate stats for someone being hyped as he is, while Crofts S L footage shows he has exceptional skill.
Just my opinion I'd be chasing young Illias from Souths , he has had a couple of years in top grade injury last year , but for me has cut it and with experience players around him , Cutho , Cook , Holmes would be my choice ........
 

TheRev

SGI NSW Cup
Good signing for me injury free will be a real leader not like the guy who thinks he is a 7 ........ The only good thing I can say about Hunt , he was tough hardly missed any games , lets hope Gutho doesn't miss too many ........
Spot on with that one.. the one thing Hunt was, was reliable.. reliably-average maybe.. but never seemed to get injured.. versus a lot of halves out there are almost stuck together with sticky-tape... Kyle tbf has been pretty robust also... but its why we need atleast 1 backup option for next year.
 

Eric

Staff
Good signing for me injury free will be a real leader not like the guy who thinks he is a 7 ........ The only good thing I can say about Hunt , he was tough hardly missed any games , lets hope Gutho doesn't miss too many ........
I think he'll be really good for LKT next year and at least 1 or 2 young backs the following year. Yelling at them from the back, telling them what's what. Though unless Flanno can pull a halfback out of a hat, or out of RU or ESL, I have fears for where the points are going to come from next year.
 

Illusion

SGI NSW Cup
I think he'll be really good for LKT next year and at least 1 or 2 young backs the following year. Yelling at them from the back, telling them what's what. Though unless Flanno can pull a halfback out of a hat, or out of RU or ESL, I have fears for where the points are going to come from next year.
Illias is the one I'd be chasing .........
 
Top