Round 11 v Panthers Sunday

J

Justadragon

SGI NSW Cup
Mug Fan said:
Dainel Saifiti, Jacob Saifiti and Mitch Barnett made their debuts that year
Click to expand...
The point I was trying to make is that it would be highly unfair that our forwards should be associated with this years debacle. I suppose its a team sport but still the way the backs have let the forwards down is criminal, and there nothing they or anyone else can do about it. Yes they have to undeservedly go through the pain to enjoy the spoils of years to come hopefully.
 
D

Dragon David

SGI NSW Cup

This bloody ref has had it in for us since the comp started in Vegas, the bastard. Remember this?

In the 88th minute of the opening-round match, referee Grant Atkins controversially penalized Dragons forward Ryan Couchman for an illegal strip on Bronson Xerri in golden point. The penalty gifted Bulldogs captain Stephen Crichton the match-winning field goal, sealing a 15-14 victory in Las Vegas. [1, 2]
The penalty was highly contentious and directly decided the outcome of the game. Here are the key details surrounding the flashpoint and its aftermath: [1]
  • The Incident: With mere seconds left on the clock in extra time, Couchman made a tackle on Xerri, dislodging the ball. While many players, commentators, and fans argued it was simply a "loose carry" from Xerri, Atkins ruled it an illegal strip.
  • Rule Changes: The controversial decision fell under a new directive issued to coaches earlier that week. The NRL had altered the interpretation of stealing the ball, meaning defenders gripping, pulling, or making specific actions to dislodge the ball could be penalized. Because the Dragons had already used their captain's challenge, they could not contest the call.
  • Coach's Reaction: St George Illawarra head coach Shane Flanagan was furious in his post-match press conference, asserting it was "a loose carry every day of the week" and that the game was "not decided in the right way".
  • Escalation: The Dragons heavily contested the officiating—losing the penalty count 9-3—and escalated their concerns to NRL management over several key rulings.
I really hope that Atkins never officiates any on field or off field games for us ever again.
 
R

redv13

SGI Jersey Flegg
jodragon40 said:
Isn't it lovely though the NRL have come out and said both the bunker and the ref got it wrong in relation to Cooks try. Would have been 12 - 6 at oranges, not saying we would have gone on with it but we will never ever know now
Click to expand...
Just the stock standard little fish getting screwed over again. Funny how it seems to be the same teams getting screwed over and the same few who always seem to benefit.

Grant Atkins: Vegas, Anzac Day then Magic round. Life member of the Penrith District Referees Association. What a legend
 
Last edited:
jodragon40

jodragon40

Staff
redv13 said:
Just the stock standard little fish getting screwed over again. Funny how it seems to be the same teams getting screwed over and the same few who always seem to benefit
Click to expand...
In my mind there is little doubt that if you look back on decisions made not only this season but past seasons it would appear on face value that some teams especially those teams in the top 4 of the table seem to get the majority of decisions than those floundering in the bottom 4.
 
R

redv13

SGI Jersey Flegg
jodragon40 said:
In my mind there is little doubt that if you look back on decisions made not only this season but past seasons it would appear on face value that some teams especially those teams in the top 4 of the table seem to get the majority of decisions than those floundering in the bottom 4.
Click to expand...
100% mate. It’s the same few who benefit and the same few who consistently get the shit stick. It’s plain to see, the bias is there every round. If that scenario was Cleary on Gutho I’m certain that’s a try.

Funny thing was exhibit A: no Penrith player was blowing up, exhibit B: Ref sent it up as a try, and exhibit C: Dylan Edward’s at halftime basically admitted that they got away with that call
 
jodragon40

jodragon40

Staff
My understanding of the rule is it firstly has to be referred to the bunker by the on field referee as a try or no try to be reviewed and he indicates that at the time of his decision. I didn't see the ref refer this try to the bunker . In fact I saw him walking back into the field of play. Was I wrong.?
 
R

redv13

SGI Jersey Flegg
jodragon40 said:
My understanding of the rule is it firstly has to be referred to the bunker by the on field referee as a try or no try to be reviewed and he indicates that at the time of his decision. I didn't see the ref refer this try to the bunker . In fact I saw him walking back into the field of play. Was I wrong.?
Click to expand...
Ref gave it a try and GA decided to be a hero and take it into his own hands and over rule it. Glad the muppet has been dropped from officiating in origin 1. Absolute arrogant prick
 
jodragon40

jodragon40

Staff
redv13 said:
Ref gave it a try and GA decided to be a hero and take it into his own hands and over rule it. Glad the muppet has been dropped from officiating in origin 1. Absolute arrogant prick
Click to expand...
Im sure and please correct me if I am wrong but the bunker in relation to tries need to be asked to review the try after referred to do so by the onfield referee. If im wrong I apologise
 
R

redv13

SGI Jersey Flegg
jodragon40 said:
Im sure and please correct me if I am wrong but the bunker in relation to tries need to be asked to review the try after referred to do so by the onfield referee. If im wrong I apologise
Click to expand...
I believe now the bunker look at all tries when given, hence the usual try confirmed after a short period before the ref allows the goal kicker to proceed. It’s a joke of a system and they still get it wrong. Damien Cook ❌, Robert Toia at Central Coast Stadium ✅.

Another example of the little fish being screwed over: Saints and GC and the usual suspects benefiting: Penrith and Roosters
 
D

Dragon David

SGI NSW Cup
Red T said:
If G Atkins was the ref he would have sin binned Cook.

He should be sacked as a ref and the bunker.

What a try it would have been !
Click to expand...
It was a solo beauty in my view Red T but cruelly denied by Atkins who was not wanting such a great moment for Cook to be praised. Atkins had all of the technology at his beck and call and in my mind purposely called it a no try and a penalty to boot (sorry for the pun) against Cook. What a bastard.:mad::mad:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top