Rookie camp 2027

The Word

SGI Jersey Flegg
Mongrel can be taught, can't it? He's not overly fast (as in leg speed but I think over 100m, he goes ok.) or agile which makes me think he might be able to make it in the backrow. I can't see him making it in the backs but the club obviously has high hopes for him so it makes me think it might be in the forwards.
From watching my son progress through the parra comp it seems to be the same kids each year that have the mongrel. Coaches try to teach the kids with mongrel a bit of self discipline. And they try to teach the disciplined kids some mongrel. But at the end of the day it’s about personality types from what I can see.
 

Eric

Staff
From watching my son progress through the parra comp it seems to be the same kids each year that have the mongrel. Coaches try to teach the kids with mongrel a bit of self discipline. And they try to teach the disciplined kids some mongrel. But at the end of the day it’s about personality types from what I can see.
I think Isaah Yeo for example doesn't have much mongrel. Whose running style to me looks a lot like that Kirk's. I really don't know but I can't see Kirk making it in the backs.
 

TheRev

SGI NSW Cup
From watching my son progress through the parra comp it seems to be the same kids each year that have the mongrel. Coaches try to teach the kids with mongrel a bit of self discipline. And they try to teach the disciplined kids some mongrel. But at the end of the day it’s about personality types from what I can see.
Ai I think its partly DNA and partly your upbringing/experiences in early life.. only a certain type of character is willing to 'willingly' run into brick walls for a living.. and thrives on that aggression/aggro with rival players (welcomes the fight)... I think outside backs can sometimes get away without the mongrel... cause they are fast and elusive, especially in years gone by.. but in the modern game wingers dont just score tries.. they also need to make big early metres... they need to welcome contact...... I remember the day Ponga and Dufty played eachother as maybe 20yr olds.. both were light outside backs.. both NRL hopefuls... but the way Ponga would put his body in front of anyone to save a try.. and Dufty would supervise tries being scored.. I saw immediately the difference.. AJ Brimson was another that came soon after those 2... he was tiny but he would risk everything to stop a try.... I mean you get some leeway as a lightweight fullback, but the best players are fearless... and forwards need plenty more scoops of that mongrel compared to backs.

I remember Josh Kerr talking about it on a podcast (before he left us the first time), he said those hitups.. especially the first tackle.. was akin to being in a car crash every time.. imagine the toll on your body..... I got the feeling Josh plays NRL because hes good at footy and its good money, but I dont think he has ever had the personality required to be a star NRL forward.. he started out as a back in lower grades... then a 2nd rower and finally got shoved into the middle.. but he didnt want to be there...
 

Eric

Staff
Ai I think its partly DNA and partly your upbringing/experiences in early life.. only a certain type of character is willing to 'willingly' run into brick walls for a living.. and thrives on that aggression/aggro with rival players (welcomes the fight)... I think outside backs can sometimes get away without the mongrel... cause they are fast and elusive, especially in years gone by.. but in the modern game wingers dont just score tries.. they also need to make big early metres... they need to welcome contact...... I remember the day Ponga and Dufty played eachother as maybe 20yr olds.. both were light outside backs.. both NRL hopefuls... but the way Ponga would put his body in front of anyone to save a try.. and Dufty would supervise tries being scored.. I saw immediately the difference.. AJ Brimson was another that came soon after those 2... he was tiny but he would risk everything to stop a try.... I mean you get some leeway as a lightweight fullback, but the best players are fearless... and forwards need plenty more scoops of that mongrel compared to backs.

I remember Josh Kerr talking about it on a podcast (before he left us the first time), he said those hitups.. especially the first tackle.. was akin to being in a car crash every time.. imagine the toll on your body..... I got the feeling Josh plays NRL because hes good at footy and its good money, but I dont think he has ever had the personality required to be a star NRL forward.. he started out as a back in lower grades... then a 2nd rower and finally got shoved into the middle.. but he didnt want to be there...
Josh Kerr is about the last person to talk about mongrel unless it's to explain the total lack of.

Blake Lawrie seemed to have it in spades.

Anyway, I'm really interested to see what they have in mind for Kirk.
 
Top