Round 18 vs Wests Tigers

R

redv13

SGI Jersey Flegg
RufusRex said:
I am comparing Jacob with the props .. i am comparing Nick to any option in the team that gets him into first grade without decent demonstrated form and cant find any ...

I do like him .. but you are pumping his tyres way beyond what his season form deserves.
Click to expand...
We’re 1-14 but let’s persist with Guler, Kerr and Lawrie to a point. Just makes zero sense to me.

Question for you: Would any other nrl club have Guler, Kerr or Lawrie on their bench??

Why should we persist with the above 3 and not get up to 9 games into Jacob and Nick considering they are both here next year and 2 of the 3 above won’t be. I wouldn’t be surprised that if Kerr asked for a release for 2027 that the club would seriously consider it.
 
RufusRex

RufusRex

SGI NSW Cup
redv13 said:
We’re 1-14 but let’s persist with Guler, Kerr and Lawrie to a point. Just makes zero sense to me.

Question for you: Would any other nrl club have Guler, Kerr or Lawrie on their bench??

Why should we persist with the above 3 and not get up to 9 games into Jacob and Nick considering they are both here next year and 2 of the 3 above won’t be. I wouldn’t be surprised that if Kerr asked for a release for 2027 that the club wouldn’t seriously consider it.
Click to expand...

Question for you: Would any other nrl club have Guler, Kerr or Lawrie on their bench??
Any other club with our top 30 - absolutely, at least one of them on the bench with Jacob.

Nick - not at all .. not ready, doesnt have the form/fitness and most importantly doesnt push Stewart/Luc/Egan evan Ryan out of an edge ... At least compare apples with apples. If Nick is in the top 17 we only play with 16 because we dont need him taking minutes of the better edge options.
 
Morgan

Morgan

SGI NSW Cup
redv13 said:
We’re 1-14 but let’s persist with Guler, Kerr and Lawrie to a point. Just makes zero sense to me.

Question for you: Would any other nrl club have Guler, Kerr or Lawrie on their bench??

Why should we persist with the above 3 and not get up to 9 games into Jacob and Nick considering they are both here next year and 2 of the 3 above won’t be. I wouldn’t be surprised that if Kerr asked for a release for 2027 that the club would seriously consider it.
Click to expand...
Problem with Kerr will be the same as Lawrie, Gutho, Sloan. No other clubs will take them.
 
R

redv13

SGI Jersey Flegg
RufusRex said:
Question for you: Would any other nrl club have Guler, Kerr or Lawrie on their bench??
Any other club with our top 30 - absolutely, at least one of them on the bench with Jacob.

Nick - not at all .. not ready, doesnt have the form/fitness and most importantly doesnt push Stewart/Luc/Egan evan Ryan out of an edge ... At least compare apples with apples. If Nick is in the top 17 we only play with 16 because we dont need him taking minutes of the better edge options.
Click to expand...
One thing I know is when Guler and Kerr are on the field together that’s about the time that things go south
 
R

redv13

SGI Jersey Flegg
RufusRex said:
Question for you: Would any other nrl club have Guler, Kerr or Lawrie on their bench??
Any other club with our top 30 - absolutely, at least one of them on the bench with Jacob.

Nick - not at all .. not ready, doesnt have the form/fitness and most importantly doesnt push Stewart/Luc/Egan evan Ryan out of an edge ... At least compare apples with apples. If Nick is in the top 17 we only play with 16 because we dont need him taking minutes of the better edge options.
Click to expand...
Luc is not wanted and has been playing less than 30 mins a game for weeks now when he’s not injured or dropped to cup
 
T

The Word

SGI Jersey Flegg
RufusRex said:
Sele is on the outer for good reasons that i wont go into here but wont be with us next year either.
Click to expand...
What's the deal with Sele, is it health related or behaviour? Surely if he's done something bad he shouldn't be used at Cup level either?

I see him as a better option than Lawrie/Guler/Kerr so not sure why he's been playing Cup for so long. I know there was speculation he was going to be allowed to leave mid season. I'm not a fan of letting players go mid season unless we have a replacement lined up. The only reason for that would be if you use the freed up funds to front load a contract offer to secure one of the young guns. Either way I'd still be using him.
 
Dragons Chris

Dragons Chris

SGI NSW Cup

Dragons team: ​

  1. Clinton Gutherson
  2. Setu Tu
  3. Mathew Feagai
  4. Valentine Holmes
  5. Tyrell Sloan
  6. Daniel Atkinson
  7. Kyle Flanagan
  8. Loko Jnr Pasifiki Tonga
  9. Damien Cook
  10. Toby Couchman
  11. Dylan Egan
  12. Hamish Stewart
  13. Ryan Couchman

  14. Jacob Liddle
  15. Luciano Leilua
  16. Josh Kerr
  17. Emre Guler

  18. Jacob Halangahu
  19. Lyhkan King-Togia

  20. Hame Sele
  21. Moses Suli
  22. Christian Tuipulotu
No changes?
 
jodragon40

jodragon40

Staff
Dragons Chris said:

Dragons team: ​

  1. Clinton Gutherson
  2. Setu Tu
  3. Mathew Feagai
  4. Valentine Holmes
  5. Tyrell Sloan
  6. Daniel Atkinson
  7. Kyle Flanagan
  8. Loko Jnr Pasifiki Tonga
  9. Damien Cook
  10. Toby Couchman
  11. Dylan Egan
  12. Hamish Stewart
  13. Ryan Couchman

  14. Jacob Liddle
  15. Luciano Leilua
  16. Josh Kerr
  17. Emre Guler

  18. Jacob Halangahu
  19. Lyhkan King-Togia

  20. Hame Sele
  21. Moses Suli
  22. Christian Tuipulotu
No changes?
Click to expand...
Surely if Suli is ok then Feigai should go he was poor last week in the centres
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top