1st Grade Readiness

A bucket of cold water on the speculation:ROFLMAO:.

He still might get a development deal. So far there are 3 confirmed but I believe 6 is the total. Reed probably won't get one cause O'Neill has one.
Well not really my initial comment was this kid has been impressive at training. One to keep an eye on in the future. . I believe Frank Facer Frank Facer mentioned him as a centre prospect
 

RedV01

SGI NSW Cup
Well not really my initial comment was this kid has been impressive at training. One to keep an eye on in the future. . I believe Frank Facer Frank Facer mentioned him as a centre prospect
No, no, no. He's a second rower. Could fill in at centre like a lot of second rowers do. Like Su'A has done several times. But his position is in the second row. If he even makes it. Remember Jackson Shreb? Tall, big, relatively fast. Dragons tried hard to address whatever his problem was but never worked out.
 
No, no, no. He's a second rower. Could fill in at centre like a lot of second rowers do. Like Su'A has done several times. But his position is in the second row. If he even makes it. Remember Jackson Shreb? Tall, big, relatively fast. Dragons tried hard to address whatever his problem was but never worked out.
Well to my old eyes if he proves himself in ressies this season he could be a chance of a top 30 contract next season either with us or another team.
 
No, no, no. He's a second rower. Could fill in at centre like a lot of second rowers do. Like Su'A has done several times. But his position is in the second row. If he even makes it. Remember Jackson Shreb? Tall, big, relatively fast. Dragons tried hard to address whatever his problem was but never worked out.
Yep he is playing up here in the Qld Cup with Norths
 

TheRev

SGI NSW Cup
Coutts is NSW cup for sure.. but I think hes one with potential that might get an upgrade for 2027.. time will tell.. its just that unless there r injuries he needs to transition to the middle to get game-time. Size wise until we see them all side by side its hard to compare, but although I think Nick probably has a wider torso, id say Coutts is the biggest overall.
 
Coutts is NSW cup for sure.. but I think hes one with potential that might get an upgrade for 2027.. time will tell.. its just that unless there r injuries he needs to transition to the middle to get game-time. Size wise until we see them all side by side its hard to compare, but although I think Nick probably has a wider torso, id say Coutts is the biggest overall.
As a coach I always desperately tried to find someone in my pack that had the uncanny ability to offload especially with 2 defenders trying to get him to ground.

When you found that person there were quite a few alternative attacking structures that you could run off that.

Yes you have those boxheads as bookends who just make the yards you need to make and a enforcer in your pack who was just as dangerous both on and off the ball. But when you found that forward who could free himself long enough to initiate 2nd phase attacking football it was the icing on the cake.

Someone like a James Graham, Trent Merrin, Luke Bailey and my favourite Rocket Rod Reddy.
 

HaydoM8

SGI Jersey Flegg
A bucket of cold water on the speculation:ROFLMAO:.

He still might get a development deal. So far there are 3 confirmed but I believe 6 is the total. Reed probably won't get one cause O'Neill has one.

My understanding is all 6 have been filled
Weatherall/Cyrus/Reed/ONeill/Buchanan and Setu Tu

On top of that is chat that Muhl has a deal of some sort which would likely push one of these 6 into the top 30 (if Muhls deal is not top 30).


The team photos taken yesterday had 32 players ...
The 25 confirmed top 30, the 6 mentioned supplementary players plus Nick who we all assume has a top 30.
Muhl was not in the shots.
 
Last edited:

TheRev

SGI NSW Cup
Muhleissen did his ACL in the grand final, so would have been october or november for surgery.. i doubt we will see much of him this year sadly.. maybe off the bench in the back end of the year with no fitness into him... but certainly wont be training.
 

HaydoM8

SGI Jersey Flegg
yep Rev, knew that ...sounds like the deal the club is giving him is related to not throwing him to the wolves with a bung knee and no earning potential.

Give him a deal, help him through his recovery and see where he ends up. If typical ACL is 9 months he may be right for the 2nd half of the season.

Hooker depth is not great and Muhl is a decent enough reserve grade hooker.
 

RedV01

SGI NSW Cup
My understanding is all 6 have been filled
Weatherall/Cyrus/Reid/ONeill/Buchanan and Setu Tu

On top of that is chat that Muhl has a deal of some sort which would likely push one of these 6 into the top 30 (if Muhls deal is not top 30).


The team photos taken yesterday had 32 players ...
The 25 confirmed top 30, the 6 mentioned supplementary players plus Nick who we all assume has a top 30.
Muhl was not in the shots.
Is that right. Where do you check the team list? When you say Reid, do you mean Kade? Isn't his name Reed? To have two halfbacks in the supplementary list seems a bit much. Maybe they had to do it for contractual reasons. Like Reed was promised to be on the list as a condition of his re-signing.
 

RedV01

SGI NSW Cup
yep Rev, knew that ...sounds like the deal the club is giving him is related to not throwing him to the wolves with a bung knee and no earning potential.

Give him a deal, help him through his recovery and see where he ends up. If typical ACL is 9 months he may be right for the 2nd half of the season.

Hooker depth is not great and Muhl is a decent enough reserve grade hooker.
Good. The kind of thing which will put the club in good stead in the player market. In theory anyway.
 

HaydoM8

SGI Jersey Flegg
Is that right. Where do you check the team list? When you say Reid, do you mean Kade? Isn't his name Reed? To have two halfbacks in the supplementary list seems a bit much. Maybe they had to do it for contractual reasons. Like Reed was promised to be on the list as a condition of his re-signing.
Yep .. my bad on the spelling ... i did mean Kade Reed just spelled it wrong.
 

GCRV

SGI NSW Cup
Would be so good if Reed played first grade this year. If Flanno deemed he was ready.

Apart from that, who else is possible? Is Williams still not training?
 
Only that Flano said in a recent interview that he was very impressed with him and he is pushing for a starting wing berth.

We could potentially see Fale and Tu on the flanks in round one.

Interesting...
I thought for sure CT if isn't hampered by his continuing hamstring issues
 
Last edited:

RedV01

SGI NSW Cup
I thought for sure CT if is hampered by his continuing hamstring issues
Sir, a hamstring strain doesn't take near on 6 months to get better. What was that insta thing they were talking about? CT liked the comment Ilias made about not getting a decent chance?

Doesn't matter anyway. CT is okay but as a winger, he'll never be more than okay due to his severe lack of speed for a winger. These 2 new dudes might turn out really good. Let's give them a chance.
 
Top