Round 11 v Panthers Sunday

[Morgan]

No alternatives

There are. LKT, Atkinson and O'Neill. No need for Kyle..

 

[Dave03]

Surely Buchanan comes in for the lame Holmes. He’s no good atm

Hope so, then Sloan on the reserves as backline injury cover.

 

[Eric]

No Halangahu. I just don't get it.

 

[jodragon40]

There are. LKT, Atkinson and O'Neill. No need for Kyle..

LKT is not 1st grade standard, I did say in another post that I was impressed by O' Neil performance against the Knights in ressies last week

 

[Morgan]

LKT is not 1st grade standard, I did say in another post that I was impressed by O' Neil performance against the Knights in ressies last week

And Kyle is???

 

[jodragon40]

And Kyle is???

Definitely a 14 in my humble view

 

[RedV01]

And Kyle is???

They need to get him TF off the books! I don't care if Hamism Stewart has to play halfback. Why not?

 

[jodragon40]

No Halangahu. I just don't get it.

Mate currently there isn't a place for him in the run on pack and he needs to have good minutes on the field so the best thing is to play him in ressies until an injury to the starting pack occurs. Just my views

 

[jodragon40]

They need to get him TF off the books! I don't care if Hamism Stewart has to play halfback. Why not?

Contracted until the end of 2027 unless sold

 

[RedV01]

Contracted until the end of 2027 unless sold

I know.

 

[blacksafake]

Yeah but he scored 17 of about 25 decent opportunities

Alex Johnston has the record not because fast but because smart and committed that is what gets him the games to score all the tries

Running into space outside Trell, Walker & Inglis prior is a bonus.

 

[Morgan]

Running into space outside Trell, Walker & Inglis prior is a bonus.

IMO people should think more about supporting actors when rating a player. Hypothetical but I guess you put Reed in that Souths team, he'd be easily better than Ashton Ward who was very good.

 

[Eric]

Mate currently there isn't a place for him in the run on pack and he needs to have good minutes on the field so the best thing is to play him in ressies until an injury to the starting pack occurs. Just my views

If I was the coach, middle rotation would be Couchman x 2, Stewart, Sele, LPT. Very young but better than any of the veterans we have. Backrow would be Halangahu and Egan. Luch as a forward utility. So:
8. LPT
9. Cook
10. Couchman
11. Egan
12. Halangahu
13. Stewart

14. Liddle
15. Couchman
16. Sele
17. Luch
18. Lawrie
19. Kyle

 

[RufusRex]

Would probably do the same .. i really like that set of forwards ...
Issue though remains leadership in the pack ... KK cannot arrive soon enough.

 

[Mug Fan]

I don't think we line up in the backs per team list could be a few changes.

 

[jodragon40]

I don't think we line up in the backs per team list could be a few changes.

Hope young Buchanan gets another shot and Sloan on a wing, just my views

 

[Justadragon]

Hope young Buchanan gets another shot and Sloan on a wing, just my views

He will be up against either Alamoti or McLean, they will both run over the top of him, I'd give him a shot at FB, just my thoughts.

 

[Mug Fan]

Hope young Buchanan gets another shot and Sloan on a wing, just my views

And a few more we are the walking wounded, I think Kyle is the only one fit.
I hate to be that guy but record loss could be the headline Sunday night.

 

[jodragon40]

And a few more we are the walking wounded, I think Kyle is the only one fit.
I hate to be that guy but record loss could be the headline Sunday night.

I was going the game but im still traumatised by watching the Anzac Day game now I won't bother

 

[Justadragon]

And a few more we are the walking wounded, I think Kyle is the only one fit.
I hate to be that guy but record loss could be the headline Sunday night.

Mate we have to acknowledge it for what it is, no matter how much we hate it. The question is , have we learnt anything out of our mistakes ?