2025 Captain

Who should be captain in 2025

  • Jack de Belin

    Votes: 7 70.0%
  • Jaydn Su'A

    Votes: 2 20.0%
  • Damien Cook

    Votes: 4 40.0%
  • Valentine Holmes

    Votes: 1 10.0%
  • Frank Molo

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Moses Suli

    Votes: 1 10.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Clint Gutherson

    Votes: 2 20.0%

  • Total voters
    10
  • Poll closed .

Ryan

SGI NSW Cup
Joint cpts hmmm , never happened in my day
Gutho is going to be on for 80 min a game, Cook won't. Gutho has vast experience as a captain, Cook doesn't. I don't know why Flanno needs to complicate the issue but lets see how they go.
 
Gutho is going to be on for 80 min a game, Cook won't. Gutho has vast experience as a captain, Cook doesn't. I don't know why Flanno needs to complicate the issue but lets see how they go.
It has always bemused me joint cpts, as I said never happened in my day
 

Ryan

SGI NSW Cup
It has always bemused me joint cpts, as I said never happened in my day
Sometimes it may be called for. Like if the natural captain has to rest during the game. I just don't think it's called for in this instance but I don't think it'll create any problems.
 

Edward

SGI Jersey Flegg
In my day he was called the vice captain
Probably Gutho is captain but Flanno wanted Cook to be treated a bit more importantly than vice captains usually are. I think Cook will be the forwards captain and Gutho will be the captain.
 
Probably Gutho is captain but Flanno wanted Cook to be treated a bit more importantly than vice captains usually are. I think Cook will be the forwards captain and Gutho will be the captain.
Gee I know I'm old and the game has passed me by but I love tradition. Captain leads the team, the vice captain has the same responsibility but only addresses the team when required such as when captain leaves the field. The captain and vice communicated with each other constantly. I wouldn't undersell the value of your vice captain but that is just me. Too many chiefs and not enough indians is not a good look in a team sport.
 

Mailroomsgi

SGI Jersey Flegg
Gee I know I'm old and the game has passed me by but I love tradition. Captain leads the team, the vice captain has the same responsibility but only addresses the team when required such as when captain leaves the field. The captain and vice communicated with each other constantly. I wouldn't undersell the value of your vice captain but that is just me. Too many chiefs and not enough indians is not a good look in a team sport.
I have no issue with it, Yeo and Cleary co-captains certainly hasn’t hindered Penrith.
Takes lots of pressure off gutho/cook by having someone else lead with them.
 

Just a Mug Fan

SGI NSW Cup
Wow making something out of nothing.
Co Captains have been regular for last 10 years
Penrith have had Yeo and Cleary last 4 years, I'm no expert but it seems to work for them.

Next years co captains.

Newcastle Knights Kalyn Ponga and Jayden Brailey 2022

North Queensland Cowboys Reuben Cotter and Tom Dearden 2024

Penrith Panthers Isaah Yeo and Nathan Cleary 2021

Roosters Tigers Sharks have all had co captains in recent years.
 

Edward

SGI Jersey Flegg
I have no issue with it, Yeo and Cleary co-captains certainly hasn’t hindered Penrith.
Takes lots of pressure off gutho/cook by having someone else lead with them.
Shows how much I know. I thought Yeo was Penrith's captain.

I don't have any issue with it. I just think Gutho will make a very good captain.
 
Wow making something out of nothing.
Co Captains have been regular for last 10 years
Penrith have had Yeo and Cleary last 4 years, I'm no expert but it seems to work for them.

Next years co captains.

Newcastle Knights Kalyn Ponga and Jayden Brailey 2022

North Queensland Cowboys Reuben Cotter and Tom Dearden 2024

Penrith Panthers Isaah Yeo and Nathan Cleary 2021

Roosters Tigers Sharks have all had co captains in recent years.
Hang on , it's just my view. Never believed in co captains, I do though believe in coexistence ask my wife of 45 yrs. I'm not saying it's wrong I'm saying in my day 1 Cpt and 1 V/Cpt that's all
 
I have no issue with it, Yeo and Cleary co-captains certainly hasn’t hindered Penrith.
Takes lots of pressure off gutho/cook by having someone else lead with them.
Me either apart from one little thing. Like work, you have toiled for years with some aspirations of one day becoming a manager then suddenly your business recruits 2 people from outside and low and behold your overlooked. It can rub some people up the wrong way and affect that business. Just my personal experience and views
 

Ryan

SGI NSW Cup
Me either apart from one little thing. Like work, you have toiled for years with some aspirations of one day becoming a manager then suddenly your business recruits 2 people from outside and low and behold your overlooked. It can rub some people up the wrong way and affect that business. Just my personal experience and views
That's a good point but I think it's fine for the Dragons as it seems there are no other talkers who were ready to take over. JDB and Su'A would've been candidates if they were talkers.
 
such a great get.. I love Cook too, but I think he will be the 2nd in command to Gutho... I really hope we have a great few years for him after he moved away from his beloved northern beaches (where I grew up too).. its strange how one clubs reject is another clubs treasure...
Ah silvertail
 

TheRev

SGI Jersey Flegg
I could understand parra letting go of RCG as he looked like he was fading but replacing Gutho with Iongi is a big step down.
If Ryles can get that Parra side flying without RCG & Gutho.. he will have my respect.. I cant even fathom it... but wont make any judgements on any side until that first 2 months go by.. the first rounds are always very random, up & down etc.
 

Mailroomsgi

SGI Jersey Flegg
If Ryles can get that Parra side flying without RCG & Gutho.. he will have my respect.. I cant even fathom it... but wont make any judgements on any side until that first 2 months go by.. the first rounds are always very random, up & down etc.
They have one of the softer draws to start the season + think they go good with that halves combination. Moses and Brown is the 2nd best halves pairing in the NRL now that luai has left Penrith. Should have them competing for a top 8 spot pending injuries
 
Top