TheRev
SGI NSW Cup
Very true re: admitting when you get it wrong (never happens on the forums)..
I didnt see much in Hamish @ Cup level, was just finding his feet, the 2 couchmen seemed better prospects and similar size/shape at the time... but even they werent 'sure things' early @19 in their first year.. it was the next year (age 20) that they showed glimpses of their potential.. then 21 (this year) they were 1st grade ready (well Toby was, Ryan has to start again now), by 22 Toby should be a level up again.. and still probably has 2-3 more years till his peak... its a process to blood new players, and to do it without losing too many first grade games in the process.... But again.. the Couchmen are genetic freaks to be doing it this early (and hence Hamish isnt far behind on the freak scale), even DeBelin who should have played a lot more origin... took years into his 20's before he became the player we remember..
Thats the hard bit, not many players are 'sure things' as teenagers... talent identification is hard and every one of em is a gamble.. and almost every kid will fall short of first grade (sad reality of how elite the NRL is)... the beauty of juniors in your own pathway is hopefully you get first choice at which ones you invest in.. but you will lose others in the process, and you wont always get it right... every club has many stories of the 1 that got away.
I didnt see much in Hamish @ Cup level, was just finding his feet, the 2 couchmen seemed better prospects and similar size/shape at the time... but even they werent 'sure things' early @19 in their first year.. it was the next year (age 20) that they showed glimpses of their potential.. then 21 (this year) they were 1st grade ready (well Toby was, Ryan has to start again now), by 22 Toby should be a level up again.. and still probably has 2-3 more years till his peak... its a process to blood new players, and to do it without losing too many first grade games in the process.... But again.. the Couchmen are genetic freaks to be doing it this early (and hence Hamish isnt far behind on the freak scale), even DeBelin who should have played a lot more origin... took years into his 20's before he became the player we remember..
Thats the hard bit, not many players are 'sure things' as teenagers... talent identification is hard and every one of em is a gamble.. and almost every kid will fall short of first grade (sad reality of how elite the NRL is)... the beauty of juniors in your own pathway is hopefully you get first choice at which ones you invest in.. but you will lose others in the process, and you wont always get it right... every club has many stories of the 1 that got away.


