Recruitment and Retention for 2025

RedVHeartbeat

SGI NSW Cup
Ackers reminded me of the one and only Bull Bailey.
Me too. What craps me big time is he put in five years of junior reps for the Saints. Deserved better, whether injury prone or not. Seems to me this board are not fussed about jettisoning St George juniors. Not be surprised if they have done same with Nick Quinn, another who did a long apprenticeship in Saints juniors. I will always fly a flag for Saints juniors as our legendary teams of the 50/60s evolved from there. The club also evolved from the district.
 

RedVHeartbeat

SGI NSW Cup
I think Daniel Meafou/Leeroy Weatherall are much better prospects than Ackers.
Disagree. Have watched Ackers progression since he was 15. You only have to acknowledge the quality of his try in Ball Cup final to see the raw talent the kid has. Has ball skills too. Injury has and will continue to cruel his career, not lack of natural talent or passion.
 
Last edited:

Chris M

SGI NSW Cup
Me too. What craps me big time is he put in five years of junior reps for the Saints. Deserved better, whether injury prone or not. Seems to me this board are not fussed about jettisoning St George juniors. Not be surprised if they have done same with Nick Quinn, another who did a long apprenticeship in Saints juniors. I will always fly a flag for Saints juniors as our legendary teams of the 50/60s evolved from there. The club also evolved from the district.
I think everyone rates Ackers but who are you going to let go in order to keep him?
 

Eric

Staff
Not sold on this guy yet. A poor fourth to our three Aussie Schoolboys currently. Did zilch to lift our Ball Cup side on the weekend. Was more impressed by Risiate Smythe.
He's a bit younger than those 3, isn't he? At that age, I guess it's a case of best guess who is going to be a gun and who is going to be a NSW Cup journeyman. Though if I had to bet my life on one of them at least having a long career in the NRL, it'd be Latu even ahead of LPT and Halangahu.
 

Edward

SGI Jersey Flegg
I think everyone rates Ackers but who are you going to let go in order to keep him?
100%. Another way to look at it is that everyone who makes it as far as a supplementary contract is very good but it's a question of are they better than the alternatives. It seems Flanno and most fans don't think Ackers is as good as the alternatives.
 

RedVHeartbeat

SGI NSW Cup
It seems Flanno and most fans don't think Ackers is as good as the alternatives.
Reason the board gave for his non retention is that he'd have not been back playing before week 5 as late as week 10. He must have a rather serious injury perhaps an ACL. I dont recall him playing before the Ball Final either and he also missed games in '23 . The poor kid is injury prone. A shame really.
 
Last edited:

Edward

SGI Jersey Flegg
Reason the board gave for his non retention is that he'd have not been back playing before week 5 as late as week 10. He must have a rather serious injury perhaps an ACL. I dont recall him playing before the Ball Final either and he also missed games in '23 . The poor kid is injury prone. A shame really.
Huge shame.
 

Mailroomsgi

SGI Jersey Flegg
Would be absolute negligence on the clubs part if Latu wasn’t extended for another year.
He’s the PERFECT middle forward for the modern game and turns 19 this year.
Will be massively disappointing if he’s not re-signed, very much Reece Robson vibes
 

TheRev

SGI Jersey Flegg
I'm sure if he's not extended there are good reasons on 1 or both sides, would be a no brainer otherwise, probably a better prospect than Stewart.
 

Dave03

SGI Jersey Flegg
We've got soo many fwd prospects coming through the system, the reality is we won't keep them all but we need to start developing the ones we keep into genuine NRL level players.
 

RedV01

SGI NSW Cup
Would be absolute negligence on the clubs part if Latu wasn’t extended for another year.
He’s the PERFECT middle forward for the modern game and turns 19 this year.
Will be massively disappointing if he’s not re-signed, very much Reece Robson vibes
Bigger loss than Robson. Even though letting him go was a monumental f*k up.
 

Mailroomsgi

SGI Jersey Flegg
This is literally the formula for getting back to the top, you can’t buy your way out of the cellar or you’ll pay overs for everyone.

Develop young guns and invest around them.
The reason we let go of Ackers or an Egan for example should to keep blue chip talent like Halangahu/Loko/Latu

We should not be losing any of that trio, their the best forwards we have produced in donkeys years
 

Mailroomsgi

SGI Jersey Flegg
Not sold on this guy yet. A poor fourth to our three Aussie Schoolboys currently. Did zilch to lift our Ball Cup side on the weekend. Was more impressed by Risiate Smythe.
Risiate Smyth is 💩 Stanley Trail is quite talented + it’s hard to have a big impact from back row if your halves/middles aren’t doing much, not Halangahu levels of talent but he’s a better back row prospect than Egan and he’s still only 19 this year. Might even get a call up to NSW u19’s.
 
Top