Eric
Staff
It worked out last year. McInnes bad luck was good for the coach. McCullough is on the books next year as well! That's 'a crime'. Everyone except Griffin can see he's no longer first grade standard.
Round 15 vs Souths
- Thread starter Eric
- Start date
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
Yep. That is what I call them as they have played together since their SG Ball days of 2019.. the year they won the premiership and announced themselves.
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
I disagree.. he was our current skipper, his dummy half sniping gave us plenty of scoring chances and his defense was faultless. Was even developing a handy kicking game too. Am betting he was on far less than Ben Hunt. So who do you think was the better value for money of the two? I know my answer. As for comparing the two Macs, no comparison..a rabbit versus a tortoise.
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
Plus the halves combo of Hunt and Amone. These two are Jekyll and Hyde together.. as bad as Widdop and Marshall. I do have faith that Junior will develop into a quality running 5/8 with some ball skills.
Last edited:
Morgan
SGI NSW Cup
He's better than Macca. No doubt at all. A lot of people were unhappy with his passing from dummy half.
RedV01
SGI NSW Cup
Worth 500~600K. He's getting around 800K to play off the bench at Shonkies.
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
Griffin just keeps going down the same road with his selections. JBD is one of the comps best ball playing locks.. he is not a prop. Blind Fredie can see that Macca is finished, Hunt is not worth the squillions he is paid and is in the wrong position, Bird is a dud in any position, McGuire is past it.. his defense is shoddy. Mbye has been thrust into the vital utility role and is doing a pretty good job of work in positions he has filled imo. Coach's only saving grace selection wise.
Last edited:
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
What was he on when here and what was he asking for before he left?
RedV01
SGI NSW Cup
Mbye is a good utility player. Not a good hooker.
RedV01
SGI NSW Cup
Not sure but McGregor and his team massively overpaid lots of players. Safe to assume it was the case for McInnes.
I also rate Bird as a utility player. Not a starting forward
jodragon40
Staff
Well another head scratcher JDB at prop and Lawrie starting, it's nonsensical, their back 3 unfortunately leave our back 3 apart from Sua for dead, that is where they will win the game im afraid on the edges. Unless the coach has a change of heart with our starting props we just will not have the necessary go forward again. Our backs match up well on a more positive note.
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
Yeh. Looks at home in the halves, fullback but does not look at home as hooker. Has he ever played there before.
RedV01
SGI NSW Cup
Final team confirmed?
RedV01
SGI NSW Cup
Tigers tried him at hooker but stopped after a few games. Because they have superstar hookers on the books. At least I guess they do. Why else would they not want hIm?
Eric
Staff
Head scratcher is one way to say it. I'd call it illogical
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
Playing where
RedV01 We have seen his earth shattering work at 5/8. He does not have a clue. Is too slow for the three quarters. Can you see him at fullback or hooker. So if not in the spine or backrow where do we put him. He was a dud when he first played for us and still is. Keeping him and McCullogh in Firsts defies belief.
Chris M
SGI NSW Cup
Sullivan, Amone, Sloan and hopefully, Muhleisen are the future. Don't think it's his fault but Hunt is the past.
RedV01
SGI NSW Cup
Injury cover, coming on in the forwards if there's no injury. Definitely not starting in the forwards when energy levels are high.Playing where
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
Adding Coric and J Hunt plus a young bull prop named Corey Ackers. Zach Herring may also be a find in the halves.
Last edited:
RedVHeartbeat
SGI NSW Cup
I dont see his energy levels as the problem but rather his ability levels.