Round 4 vs Parramatta

RedV01

RedV01

SGI NSW Cup
jodragon40 said:
Makes sense, personally Sloan straight back in at fullback. I have found that there is no better medicine for a young player touted to be the next big thing than to unexpectedly drop them. Ramsay back on the wing. Starting pack spot on. Mbye back to bench replacing McCullough who will have his work cut out keeping Cook quiet. Be looking forward to the edge battle where this game will be won Sua & Sims v Murray & Arrow in my humble opinion. Sua will lift against his old team. Lawrie has had his last chance .Suli ran for 175m 2nd only to Rav his post tackle metres made our forwards look like teddy bears 75m next was Molo. Suli is coming good. Bird was awful missing every 3rd tackle he made you can't as a team carry players missing every 3rd tackle. You need more JDB who didn't miss a tackle. I once again question openly the coaches use of our best forward JDB only 47 mins for a player who can play the 80, something not right there. Forward hit up well those stats are embarrassing Lawrie 3 for 23m Sims Molo 12 each. You need your forwards consistently making 10 hit ups a game for 100m until then God help us.
Click to expand...
I don't think JDB has ever been an 80min player but he has always played way more than 47. Against Penrith he played for over 70min and was awesome. He should be on for the first 30min, get a break and come on for the last 30min.
 
jodragon40

jodragon40

SGI NSW Cup
RedV01 said:
I don't think JDB has ever been an 80min player but he has always played way more than 47. Against Penrith he played for over 70min and was awesome. He should be on for the first 30min, get a break and come on for the last 30min.
Click to expand...
In my view he could play 80 min if asked if you are going to replace him I agree with your assumption
 
Morgan

Morgan

SGI NSW Cup
RedV01 said:
I don't think JDB has ever been an 80min player but he has always played way more than 47. Against Penrith he played for over 70min and was awesome. He should be on for the first 30min, get a break and come on for the last 30min.
Click to expand...
Agree. If pushed, as he was against Penrith, could give him only an extra 5min break at the end and beginning of the halves.
 
Eric

Eric

Staff
jodragon40 said:
Makes sense, personally Sloan straight back in at fullback. I have found that there is no better medicine for a young player touted to be the next big thing than to unexpectedly drop them. Ramsay back on the wing. Starting pack spot on. Mbye back to bench replacing McCullough who will have his work cut out keeping Cook quiet. Be looking forward to the edge battle where this game will be won Sua & Sims v Murray & Arrow in my humble opinion. Sua will lift against his old team. Lawrie has had his last chance .Suli ran for 175m 2nd only to Rav his post tackle metres made our forwards look like teddy bears 75m next was Molo. Suli is coming good. Bird was awful missing every 3rd tackle he made you can't as a team carry players missing every 3rd tackle. You need more JDB who didn't miss a tackle. I once again question openly the coaches use of our best forward JDB only 47 mins for a player who can play the 80, something not right there. Forward hit up well those stats are embarrassing Lawrie 3 for 23m Sims Molo 12 each. You need your forwards consistently making 10 hit ups a game for 100m until then God help us.
Click to expand...
Is Ramsey a better winger than Feagai? Feagai needs to get more involved but from his involvements, he looked strong. Stronger than Ramsey.
 
jodragon40

jodragon40

SGI NSW Cup
Eric said:
Is Ramsey a better winger than Feagai? Feagai needs to get more involved but from his involvements, he looked strong. Stronger than Ramsey.
Click to expand...
Yes like the look of Feagai hard to pick between the two Ramsay has had limited opportunities because we favour our right side of Lomax and Rav but we need to develop the left between Suli and his winger
 
Eric

Eric

Staff
jodragon40 said:
Yes like the look of Feagai hard to pick between the two Ramsay has had limited opportunities because we favour our right side of Lomax and Rav but we need to develop the left between Suli and his winger
Click to expand...
Specially in light of the form of Zac Lomax so far this year........
 
RedV01

RedV01

SGI NSW Cup
jodragon40 said:
Agree he needs to be more confident and selective hasn't been the same since that thumb injury
Click to expand...
The bottom line is, the whole team should be better but the most immediate problem is the forwards. If Griffin doesn't go with a starting pack of Molo, Woods, McCullough, Su'a, Sims, de Belin, it'll be something other than form.

I'd also like Sloan and Amone to come back in. Now they have gotten a kick up the ass by beIng dropped, I expect both will fire up.
 
jodragon40

jodragon40

SGI NSW Cup
RedV01 said:
The bottom line is, the whole team should be better but the most immediate problem is the forwards. If Griffin doesn't go with a starting pack of Molo, Woods, McCullough, Su'a, Sims, de Belin, it'll be something other than form.

I'd also like Sloan and Amone to come back in. Now they have gotten a kick up the ass by beIng dropped, I expect both will fire up.
Click to expand...
Agree
 
Chris M

Chris M

SGI NSW Cup
RedV01 said:
The bottom line is, the whole team should be better but the most immediate problem is the forwards. If Griffin doesn't go with a starting pack of Molo, Woods, McCullough, Su'a, Sims, de Belin, it'll be something other than form.

I'd also like Sloan and Amone to come back in. Now they have gotten a kick up the ass by beIng dropped, I expect both will fire up.
Click to expand...
One more problem is that last night they looked like a slow team. McCullough has been a really good player but the way his opposite number ran past him last night to score was alarming. Then when Blake scored that runaway try, no one in our team was making up ground chasing. A slow 5/8, one slow centre in Suli and Lomax is hardly JAC. Rava and Feagai both seem on the slow side for wingers. And Mbye is as slow as a wet week for a fullback.

I agree, he has to bring Amone and Sloan back into the starting side. Hopefully they have learned their lesson.
 
Eric

Eric

Staff
Chris M said:
One more problem is that last night they looked like a slow team. McCullough has been a really good player but the way his opposite number ran past him last night to score was alarming. Then when Blake scored that runaway try, no one in our team was making up ground chasing. A slow 5/8, one slow centre in Suli and Lomax is hardly JAC. Rava and Feagai both seem on the slow side for wingers. And Mbye is as slow as a wet week for a fullback.

I agree, he has to bring Amone and Sloan back into the starting side. Hopefully they have learned their lesson.
Click to expand...
It seems Griffin is going with his old favourites sometimes. I think he's too professional for that but it's the way it sometimes seems to me. Connor Muhleisen is also a tackling machine who also can play 80min who also gives good service out of dummy half. Not sure what his running game is like but it can't be worse than McCullough's. Muhleisen can't come into the side now because he's not in the top 30 but he should be!
 
jodragon40

jodragon40

SGI NSW Cup
Eric said:
It seems Griffin is going with his old favourites sometimes. I think he's too professional for that but it's the way it sometimes seems to me. Connor Muhleisen is also a tackling machine who also can play 80min who also gives good service out of dummy half. Not sure what his running game is like but it can't be worse than McCullough's. Muhleisen can't come into the side now because he's not in the top 30 but he should be!
Click to expand...
He is in the development squad so can't play until halfway through the season unfortunately, seems another shining light at the end of a darkening tunnel that we need and you are correct in the game these days is greatly quicker than in mine so you need size speed and stamina in at least 10 of your starting 17 in my view
 
Last edited:
Eric

Eric

Staff
jodragon40 said:
He is in the development squad so can't play until halfway through the season unfortunately, seems another shining light at the end of a darkening tunnel that we need and you are correct in the game these days is greatly quicker than in mine so you need size speed and stamina in at least 10 of your starting 17 in my view
Click to expand...
I didn't know he's in the development squad. Good to know. Surely he'll get a chance sooner rather than later. Who else, if anyone might a get a start after round 10 from the development squad? Jackson Shereb? Josh Coric?
 
Morgan

Morgan

SGI NSW Cup
Chris M said:
One more problem is that last night they looked like a slow team. McCullough has been a really good player but the way his opposite number ran past him last night to score was alarming. Then when Blake scored that runaway try, no one in our team was making up ground chasing. A slow 5/8, one slow centre in Suli and Lomax is hardly JAC. Rava and Feagai both seem on the slow side for wingers. And Mbye is as slow as a wet week for a fullback.

I agree, he has to bring Amone and Sloan back into the starting side. Hopefully they have learned their lesson.
Click to expand...
Yep. Agree with everyone else. Amone and Sloan have to come back in. If Hook goes with the forward pack as far as I can see everyone wants, Sloan and Amone won't be under so much defensive pressure. And will have more time to get their running game going!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top