Just a Mug Fan
SGI NSW Cup
Half the team get needled every week and more at halftime.
Round 21: Dragons vs Penrith Panthers - 28 July @ 2PM
- Thread starter Dave03
- Start date
Half the team get needled every week and more at halftime.
jodragon40
Staff
Even in my day in the 90s you simply cannot afford to be carrying an injured player against one of the elite teams in your comp. It just isn't fair, even back then to the other 14 players . There is nothing to be gained because that player or players will be found out in the heat of the battle.
jodragon40
Staff
If that's the case we have done very well to be in the position on the table we are currently in.
jodragon40
Staff
To my eye it's a mental thing, a lack of confidence. Players such as Sloan thrive on confidence but half the fight these days is not just being physically ready but mentally ready for the rigours of 1sts.
Edward
SGI Jersey Flegg
True. But I think the fact he has a bit of speed can force opposition to take certain precautions. For example, with the team as is with Fegai in for Sloan would allow Penrith wingers and fullback to stand up in the line because any kick in behind will be easily cleaned up. Have wingers stay up for the entire set and challenge Hunt or Liddle if they are good enough to kick a 40-20. Penrith will be confident of defending their line.
lestweforget2010
SGI Junior League
Should Flanagan be dropped for Marschke? He seems to be a much more creative player in attack which I think is what we need.
Chris M
SGI NSW Cup
Amen. Been saying it, and getting a baking for it, for a couple of months. Since the last Penrith game.
jodragon40
Staff
Wishful thinking
Chris M
SGI NSW Cup
Because Kyle's dad is the coach or Kyle at 5/8 is better for this team?
jodragon40
Staff
Blood is thicker than water. Let us not forget he wasn't originally signed to become our apparent 2nd playmaker
jodragon40
Staff
Let's be brutally honest here nobody expects us to win, so there is no pressure on the players or team this can be advantageous in some instances. A full house and playing at Win are two more positives as is our h2h statistics. Unfortunately that's where it ends. Match ups in the halves, the playmakers we have Hunt/Flanagan v Lui/ Cleary. In the engine room we have F Molo/JDB v Leota/ JFH, rear engine room, RFM/Su'a/ and fan favourite Eisenhuth v Yeo/Martin/Sorensen. Two intriguing match ups in the backs for me, Lomax v To'o that's where I'd be concentrating my ariel attack and in the centres Suli v the inexperienced McLean. However to utilise the Lomax v To'o height mismatch, our pack has to get us over the halfway line so we can get in attacking kicks, then of course Hunt's kicks have to be on song. We need luck but you make your own luck, the bounce of the ball, penalty count, 6 again count will all play a role. In my view to be competitive we have to restrict our missed tackle count, restrict their 2nd phase attacking opportunities and complete our sets. Time will tell . Good luck to the big red v.
Just a Mug Fan
SGI NSW Cup
Jesse is injured again. He has mangaged to play one full game of football in the last 2 months
jodragon40
Staff
Not that it would happen anyway the coach picking Marschke ahead of his son but that seems to be our problem at the club for sometime now , our inability to have that depth which places actual pressure on our 1sts team to perform consistently or be replaced
GCRV
SGI NSW Cup
Unfortunately, not confident about this. Also refs won't worry about pissing off the Dragons with arbitrary 6-again calls but will worry about pissing off the Panthers.
TheRev
SGI Jersey Flegg
Flanno said he had Jesse on ice for that Broncos game, he didnt play him the week before in cup which was touch and go... worked out really well in the end and we just jagged that huge victory... he only made it part way thru the game, but we had Bird that day which was good.
Must be a concern though ahead of who is our halves backup for 2025, I still like the idea of Volkman (a genuine 7 with potential) but I have no idea the state of his shoulder or if there are ill-feelings on either side of the ledger.
Must be a concern though ahead of who is our halves backup for 2025, I still like the idea of Volkman (a genuine 7 with potential) but I have no idea the state of his shoulder or if there are ill-feelings on either side of the ledger.
GCRV
SGI NSW Cup
Hopefully LKT is ok for first grade. But he still seems more a runner than playmaker. So won't suit partnering Hunt's game.
TheRev
SGI Jersey Flegg
Not sure what to make of LKT, he was god-mode at SG level with all that space, and hes solid in nsw cup, hes not rly a fullback but hes making a fist of it.. I dont think he has the speed rly to dominate that position longterm but hes getting heaps of experience... hes pretty good at chiming into the line and finding the right pass to put someone away.. ive seen him do that in NSW Cup also on both sides of the field... but if I was going to choose between him and Marshke even at cup level.. tbh Marchke is far more developed... which gives an indication that I dont think LKT would just be thrown into 1st grade anytime soon.
I really just want a genuine 7 in our system somewhere.. man-manager, kicking-game.. and then if Hunt gets injured.. or whatever happens.. maybe this guy is pressuring.. maybe he forces Hunt into 6, 9 or 14 at some point... Volkman just seems a cheap speculator, I liked what he did before last year @ the warriors.. I dont think Flanno would spend the money to go after like an Ilias or some such... There are guys like Sezer too who would be on the outer.. I dunno if that level of halfback would be someone we would chase.
Just a Mug Fan
SGI NSW Cup
No one is suited to Hunt, he has churned through partners and juniors with no results.
They only time we have dominated in attack is when Widdop was the senior partner.
Edward
SGI Jersey Flegg
100% agree. With such a halfback even the Feagai's could be decent 5/8s. Or as you say, Hunt himself. Pass, tackle, break a tackle here and there and that's it. Not saying they'd be really good 5/8s but with that kind of halfback, don't see why they wouldn't do ok.
Eric
Staff
I think you are right about LKT. I've been thinking it for a little while but wanted to delude myself it isn't true. He might go well yet but not with Hunt at halfback. With Hunt at halfback, I think they might screw each other up with their running games.
How is his kicking in general play?