jodragon40
SGI NSW Cup
It would appear so
Recruitment and Retention for 2024
- Thread starter RedVHeartbeat
- Start date
Chris M
SGI NSW Cup
He's full of heart for sure. Gets belted over and over and gets up and keeps coming until he's making good metres toward the backend of games. But talent is important even for props. Sadly, Blake lacks it. But starting him on the bench is something I've seen people call for over and over on this forum and in other places. I think it's a good idea. If the Dragons has decent depth up front. Frank Molo should be one starting prop. Maybe Sele should be the other.
RedVictory
SGI Jersey Flegg
Looks like we won’t be reuniting with big Luch after all. Raiders are now front runners for his signature.
Morgan
SGI NSW Cup
Asking for 900k a season for 4 years!!!! No thanks. I think about 450k for 2 years is right.
Illusion
SGI Jersey Flegg
Here we go again use us to kick start their dealings ....... https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nr...t/news-story/b991857630cfb2825130aac504172c8c
Chris M
SGI NSW Cup
I must have missed him playing for the Cowboys because I'm surprised he'd ask for anything near 900K. Though I think he could be a decent game breaker for us. A forward with a bit of skill but not the hardest worker.
jodragon40
SGI NSW Cup
Most importantly he's respected by his team-mates and is now considered a senior member. It would be extremely difficult for the coach to drop him to the bench unless injured or suspended. So it is what it is.
jodragon40
SGI NSW Cup
As I indicated in another thread not for me. His work rate, his discipline, his statistics would indicate to me he's at best a $600k a year player not a $900k player and wouldn't make my run on team. Forget this fallacy and forget him and develop and move on with our juniors and reserve grade backrowers
Eric
Staff
I've been saying it forever. It's one of my pet hates. That along with the slow backline. And the terrible defence. And Hunt carrying on like he's the second coming of Reg Gasnier. I rate Lawrie if played right. That means leaving him off in the opening exchanges but giving him longer on the field. Good for him and good for the team, IMO.
Remember we already got RFM. I think he might be a better backrower than Luch.
This is the second time I've kind of disagreed with
jodragon40 recently. I must be getting bolder. I think the modern game is 17 on 17. I doubt anyone would blink if Blake started on the bench. And if they did, too bad. It's for the good of the team.
Eric
Staff
Don't forget the signing on RFM. I rate Luch as a player but is he needed at this time? Unless Su'A has one foot out the door, can't see us needing Luch.
RedVictory
SGI Jersey Flegg
Luch will always haunt me. Was so high on him coming through. He was damn near a 130kg five-eighth
RedV01
SGI NSW Cup
True
RedV01
SGI NSW Cup
Liquid courage?This is the second time I've kind of disagreed with
Edward
SGI Jersey Flegg
An ongoing problem. 130kg forwards who play like 5/8s. 100kg halfbacks like Hutchinson. 60 or 70kg fullbacks like Dufty, Ramsey and Sloan.
jodragon40
SGI NSW Cup
I thought we are in agreeance. I thought I said he would be off the bench if I was still coaching, didn't I?I've been saying it forever. It's one of my pet hates. That along with the slow backline. And the terrible defence. And Hunt carrying on like he's the second coming of Reg Gasnier. I rate Lawrie if played right. That means leaving him off in the opening exchanges but giving him longer on the field. Good for him and good for the team, IMO.
Remember we already got RFM. I think he might be a better backrower than Luch.
This is the second time I've kind of disagreed with
jodragon40
SGI NSW Cup
Wasn't he a talent? But once again there is a big difference between playing back then U19s and 1st grade. So many players over the years have been taunted as the next big thing and for one reason or another fail to live up to those wraps
Eric
Staff
Yep. I disagreed with the part about him being a team leader who must start. That's why I said, "kind of disagree" not "disagree".
jodragon40
SGI NSW Cup
I said he is now considered a senior member of the squad and in the leadership group thats why they won't put him on the bench unfortunately
Eric
Staff
I think they won't put him on the bench because....... I don't know. Out dated notion that the best prop needs to start?
Ryan
SGI Jersey Flegg
I don't know much about Fifita except for a few posters here talking about him positively. If he's a big prop, tough prop, hardworking prop but runs out of steam quicker than Blake, that might force Flannos to start him. So starting props Frank Molo and Fifita. Blake and Sele on the bench.